| IAN's World
of Sports |
 |
 |
VIOLENCE IN SPORTS

Some argue
that any action in sport is morally and legally allowable—because
it’s “part of the game.” For example, in boxing, you
can punch someone, but at the supermarket you cannot.
You can knock someone over on the football field but
not on the sidewalk. Why? What violent actions, if any,
should not be permissible in sport?

Is it
wrong to punch someone in a basketball game? Is it wrong
for a pitcher to intentionally throw a baseball at a
batter’s head? Is it wrong for a hockey player to intentionally
hit someone on the head with their stick?

Once you
determine whether or not certain types of actions are
wrong, determine what—if anything—should be punishable
by law in sports? Should athletes be able to be punished
for violence in sport? If so, which actions?

Some argue
that certain sports have an unspoken level of acceptability—an
“ethos”—that others outside of the sport cannot understand.
Should we allow sports to police themselves or should
we allow the outside courts to become involved? The
sports leagues all have their own sets of rules and
punishments—some punishments occur within the game (i.e.
fouls, penalties, and even game expulsions) and some
occur outside (i.e. game suspensions, fines, etc.).
Should that be punishment enough?
WHAT IS A GAME? HOW DOES IT DIFFER FROM A SPORT?

Do they
each require that the participant have fun? If they
are not having fun, does it cease to be a game or a
sport? What about the involvement of luck? Skill? How
do you define these and what makes them different? What
makes them different from other activities such as work,
education, leisure? Can you make a list of qualities
that separate games from all other activities? How is
a game different from taking an exam that is graded
on a curve? How is it different from earning a raise
at the office? From driving home?

Are the
following considered games? If you disagree with someone,
on what grounds do you disagree?

1. Frisbee

2. Russian
Roulette

3. Boxing

4. Patience

5. Bull
Fighting

6. War

7. Olympic
Ball Room Dancing

If we
can’t agree on the list of qualities that distinguishes
the class of “games” and we can’t agree on how the term
is applied (to the above cases, for example) then how
do words like “games” get their meaning in the first
place? If words are not exact, then what problems might
we encounter in our daily lives?